Why Being the “Easy” One Is Quietly Erasing You (And How to Get Yourself Back)

Listen on: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · or wherever you get your podcasts

---

You’re at the restaurant, looking at the dessert menu.

You see chocolate cake. You think, yum, that sounds delicious.

Then your partner looks up and asks, “What do you feel like?”

And you freeze.

Not because you don’t know what you want. You do know what you want. But before you can say it, your brain does this thing – automatically, before you even catch it happening. It scans their face. It runs the past few times you talked about dessert. It reads the menu for what they’d probably want. What would make them happy. What would make them happy with you.

And even though part of you wants to say “I feel like chocolate cake,” what comes out is: “Oh, I don’t know. What do you feel like?”

Later – when the tiramisu shows up, or on the drive home, or while you’re brushing your teeth – you feel that familiar tug. Why can’t I just be honest? Why can’t I just ask for what I want? Why do I always, with everyone, turn into whatever they need at my own expense?

And then the scarier question underneath it: Am I just constantly lying to everyone? Am I a fraud – pretending to be someone I’m not?

I need you to hear me on this one, because it’s important:

You’ve not been lying to everyone you love. You’ve been surviving. There’s a name for what you’ve been doing, there’s a reason you got so good at it, and there is absolutely a way to stop abandoning yourself to keep everyone else happy.

About this episode

The first stretch of this season built the foundation – how your brain works, where the wound comes from, why relationship advice was never written for you…. Episode 21 walks straight into one of the most quietly devastating patterns underneath all of it: the performance. The being-agreeable, going-with-the-flow, becoming-what-everyone-needs performance so many of us have run in every relationship we’ve ever had.

In this one, I break down what that performance actually is (it has a clinical name, and it’s not “fake”), why it goes deepest in our romantic relationships specifically, and why there’s real grief in realizing you’ve been doing it. Then – because I’m not going to leave you sitting in the grief – I give you four small, doable ways to start letting the real you out. Not by blowing up your life. Just by opening the door a crack.

If you’ve ever wondered why you can have a partner, a home, a whole life, and still feel lonely in a way that makes no sense on paper – this is the episode that explains it.

What you’ll learn

• Why “fake” is the wrong word for what you’ve been doing – and what it actually is
• The three layers of masking (hiding, compensating, and the one that costs the most)
• Why the mask goes deepest in your romantic relationship, not with strangers or coworkers
• How the “good girl” training you got as a kid set this whole pattern in motion
• Why you can be right next to your partner and still feel completely alone
• Why the grief you’re feeling isn’t proof you wasted your life – it’s a signal to follow
• Four small ways to start unmasking without blowing up your relationship (starting with what you actually want for dinner)

Grief only shows up for the things that matter – and this matters. You matter.

Resources mentioned

• Free quiz – Is It Actually Me?: JennaDalton.com/quiz
• Come say hi on Instagram: @neurodivergentlovelab

Ready to go deeper?

If you saw yourself in this episode and you’re ready to start finding your way back to yourself:

• Take the free quiz – Is It Actually Me?: twelve questions, five minutes, built for exactly this fog. It helps you sort out whether the stuck feeling is your wiring, your relationship, or the two tangled together.
• Grab the free workbook – How to Feel Understood in Love: a gentle place to start putting words to what you actually need. Find it at JennaDalton.com/lovemap.
• Book a free 15-minute consult (Alberta only): if you’re in Alberta and curious about working together one-on-one, you can book here.

Loved this episode?

Subscribe so you don’t miss what’s coming, leave a rating wherever you listen, and send this one to the friend who’s always the “easy” one – the low-maintenance one, the one who never makes a fuss. She might need to hear that she’s allowed to take up space too.

---

Episode transcript

This transcript has been lightly edited for readability.

Cold open

You’re sitting at the restaurant looking at the dessert menu.

You notice chocolate cake and think, “Yum, that sounds delicious.”

Your partner looks up at you and says, “What do you feel like?”

And you freeze.

Not because you don’t know what you want. You do know what you want. Right? But the first thing your brain does, automatically, before you even know it’s happening, is scan their face, think about past experiences, and look at the menu searching for what you think they would like.

What would make them happy. What would make them happy with you.

And even though part of you wants to say “I feel like chocolate cake,” you say, “Oh, I don’t know. What do you feel like?”

Then later — maybe when the tiramisu comes, or when you’re driving home, or as you’re getting ready for bed — you notice that familiar tug of why can’t I just be honest with them? Why can’t I just ask for what I want? Why do I always, with everyone, have to just be agreeable and go with the flow and not make a fuss and become what everyone else needs at my own expense?

That heaviness is something a lot of the women I work with carry.

And it comes with another question: Am I just incapable of telling the truth? Am I just constantly lying to everyone? Am I a fraud — pretending to be someone I’m not?

Let me be clear. You have not been lying to everyone you love. You’ve been surviving.

There’s actually another name for what you’ve been doing, there’s a reason you got so good at it, and there is absolutely a way to stop abandoning yourself to make everyone else happy.

Intro

This is the Neurodivergent Love Lab. I’m Jenna Dalton, a psychologist who’s AuDHD. I help ADHD, autistic, and AuDHD women feel truly understood and deeply loved. And this is Episode 21: Why Being the “Easy” One Is Quietly Erasing You (And How to Get Yourself Back).

Today we’re going to talk about performance. Particularly how us neurodivergent women tend to perform — and some of us have performed in every relationship we’ve ever had.

We’re going to talk about what that performance actually is, why it’s not the same thing as being fake, why there’s grief in realizing it’s something you do and how that’s worth honouring, and then what it looks like to start letting the fully authentic you out. Not all at once. Nobody’s asking you to blow up your life by becoming a completely different person overnight. Let’s just open the door a crack, okay?

You didn’t lie. You adapted.

Okay. Let’s start with the word that’s probably been swirling through your head when I said “performance,” because I want to take it off the table right now.

Fake.

I’ve been fake this whole time. None of it was real. They fell in love with someone who doesn’t exist.

I need you to hear me on this. That word is wrong, and it’s cruel, and it’s doing you a genuine disservice.

What you’ve been doing has a clinical name. It’s called masking, or camouflaging, and it’s one of the most documented features of how neurodivergence shows up in women specifically. And here’s the part that matters: it was never a choice you sat down and made. It was an adaptation you built to stay safe.

Let me actually break it down, because “masking” gets thrown around a lot and I don’t think people realize how many moving parts are in there. Researchers describe it in about three layers.

The first is the hiding. Swallowing the reaction. Forcing the eye contact even though it feels like staring into the sun. Sitting on your hands so you don’t stim. Keeping your face arranged into “pleasant and normal” while your nervous system is doing something else entirely underneath.

The second is the compensating. This is the clever one. This is where you built the scripts. Where you studied how other people did conversation and reverse-engineered it. Where you borrowed a laugh, a phrase, a way of standing, from a friend or a character in a show, and folded it into your own repertoire because it worked. A lot of neurodivergent women are, frankly, brilliant at this. You became a student of human behaviour because you had to in order to feel like you belong.

And the third is the assimilating. Which is the one that costs the most. That’s forcing yourself to blend in even when it hurts. Going to the loud thing. Staying at the party. Saying yes. Pushing yourself along on a day when you had nothing left, because stopping would mean being seen, and being seen felt dangerous.

Now here’s the thing the research says that I really want you to sit with. For a lot of women, this becomes so automatic, so early, and so constant, that you lose track of where the performance ends and you begin.

That’s not fakeness. That’s not manipulation. That’s a person who learned, very young, that the unedited version of her got a certain look. Got corrected. Got called too much, too sensitive, too weird, too intense. And so she got to work, the way smart kids do, and she built something that got a better reception.

You didn’t maliciously lie to everyone. You did what you had to do to be let in. To be accepted. To be loved.

Why the mask goes deepest in your relationship

That hits hard, right? Stick with me. I’m going to share some of the reasons why this happened in the first place, and help you navigate it differently going forward.

So if masking is something a lot of us do everywhere — at work, with family, at the school pickup — why does it hit so hard specifically in our relationships? Why is that the realization that levels people?

A few reasons.

The first is that your romantic relationship is where the stakes are highest, so the mask works hardest. Think about it. Rejection from a stranger stings for an afternoon. Rejection from the person you’ve chosen, the person you go home to, the person who’s supposed to be your safe place — that one your nervous system treats as a genuine catastrophe. And if you carry rejection sensitivity, which a huge number of us do, that threat sits even closer to the surface. So the part of you that manages other people’s impressions of you doesn’t relax in your relationship. It goes into overdrive. The most important audience gets the most polished performance.

The second reason is the good-girl training underneath it, and this is specific to how girls get raised. You were taught, in a thousand small ways, that being loveable meant being agreeable. Easy. Low-maintenance. Not a lot of trouble. Nobody sat you down and said, “and what do you actually need, and how do we make sure you get it.” The script you got was: be the kind of person who’s easy to love. So you became her. And she’s lovely — like your favourite heroine in that rom-com. She’s just also a full-time job.

The third reason is the one from your dating history, and I did a whole episode on this back in Episode 17, “Why Do I Keep Choosing the Wrong Partners,” so I’ll keep it short. But in those first few months of a relationship, the shine is on max. You mirror. You’re up for anything. You’re funny and easy and low-drama. And your partner falls for that person, of course they do, and then somewhere down the line the real you starts arriving — the tired one, the one with the sensory needs and the recovery days — and it doesn’t feel like “here’s more of her.” To both of you it can feel like a bait and switch. When the truth is much sadder and much more ordinary: the first version was never sustainable, because it was a performance, and performances can’t last forever.

And here’s the loneliest part, the part that I think is actually underneath the whole realization.

When you mask with your partner, you can be lying right next to another human being, in your own home, in your own bed, and be completely alone. Because they’re relating to the version of you that you’re producing for them. And some quiet part of you knows it. So you get this ache that makes no sense on paper. I have a partner. I’m not single. Why do I feel so lonely? You feel lonely because there’s a part of you that you’ve kept off-stage and you have yet to introduce her to the one person she most needs to meet.

The grief — and what it’s telling you

Now let’s dive into the grief in all this and what it’s actually telling you.

Because this isn’t just some nice-to-know info we’re talking about. There’s loss here.

The grief is real. You’re grieving something specific. You’re grieving all the years you spent performing for people who might have loved the fully authentic you if you’d ever felt safe enough to show her. You’re grieving relationships that ended and you never knew why, and now you have a horrible suspicion the why was that nobody ever actually got to meet the entirety of you. You might be grieving the exhaustion of it. The sheer cost. Realizing how much of your energy, your entire life, went into a performance you didn’t even decide to compose. It just happened.

If you’ve listened to me talk about diagnosis on this show, you’ll know I describe it as relief and grief all in one package. This is the same thing. The relief is real: oh, there’s a reason, I’m not broken, it has a name. And the grief is real: and I can’t get those years back.

Both are true. You’re allowed to feel both.

But here’s the reframe I want to give you.

Grief only shows up for things that matter.

You don’t grieve something you didn’t care about. The fact that this hurts is proof of how much this matters to you. How much you wanted to be known. That ache you’re feeling isn’t a sign something’s wrong with you. It’s your own self, finally raising her hand, saying: I’m still in here. I’d like a turn now.

That’s not a wound to be managed. That’s a signal to be followed.

Because you can’t un-know this. Once you’ve seen the performance, you can’t fully un-see it. And that feels like a curse in week one. But it’s actually the opening. You’ve spent your whole life so fused with the mask you couldn’t tell it apart from yourself. The fact that you can suddenly see the seam? That’s the beginning of getting to choose.

How to let the real you out (without blowing up your life)

Okay. Let’s get practical, because I don’t want to leave you sitting in the grief with nowhere to go. But I want to be really clear about the pace here. Unmasking is not a demolition project. You are not going to walk in tomorrow and announce, “the woman you decided to spend your life with was a construct, behold the real me.” Please don’t do that. That’s not the assignment.

The assignment is small, true things. A crack in the door. Here are four ways to start.

Move one: find your actual yes and your actual no — in private, first

Before you can show anyone the real you, you have to go find her, and she’s usually buried under decades of “I don’t mind, whatever you want.”

So practice, alone, with no audience, on the lowest-stakes stuff imaginable. What do you actually want for dinner, if nobody else’s preference existed? What music do you like when no one’s judging your taste? Which parts of your day do you genuinely enjoy, and which ones are you white-knuckling because you think you’re supposed to enjoy them?

Start there. Deliberately. Because the muscle that says “here’s what I want” has probably not been used in a long time, and it’s weak, and it doesn’t need you lifting 300lbs of asserting your needs on day one. You rebuild it with tiny reps on things that don’t scare you, long before you use it on anything that does.

Move two: let out one true thing at a time — treat it like information

Once you’ve got a few real preferences in hand, you start letting small ones out into the relationship. Not a flood of all the things. One true thing.

“Actually, I don’t love that restaurant, the noise wipes me out. Can we do the quieter one?”

“I know I usually say I don’t mind, but I do have a preference this time, and it’s this.”

“I need a slow morning on Sundays. That’s not me pulling away from you. It’s how I recover after a busy week.”

And here’s the reframe that makes it survivable, because I know your stomach dropped a bit. Every small true thing you let out is information you’re gathering, about them.

How did they take it? Did they get curious, or did they get weird? Did they make room, or make you pay for it? You’re not confessing. You’re finding out whether this is a relationship that has room for the realest you. And most of the time, the answer is a lot warmer than the terrified part of you predicts.

Move three: notice when you’re performing — no fixing required, yet

For a couple of weeks, all I want you to do is catch yourself in the act. You don’t have to change anything. Just notice. Oh, I just laughed at something I didn’t find funny. Oh, I just said “it’s fine” and it wasn’t. Oh, I just agreed to a thing I don’t want to do.

Don’t judge it. Judging it just adds shame, and shame makes you mask harder. Just notice, with something like curiosity. Because you can’t stop doing a thing you can’t see yourself doing. The noticing is the work at this stage. The changing comes later, and it comes much more easily once you can actually catch the moment.

Move four: pick one safe person, and let them meet a little more of you

You do not owe the whole world your unmasked self. Some rooms aren’t safe, and masking in them is a legitimate tool, and I will never tell you to drop it where it protects you.

But pick one person. The safest one you’ve got. Your partner, ideally, or a friend if that feels like less of a leap to start. And with that one person, on purpose, let a little more of the authentic you out. Say the weird thought out loud. Let them see you stim. Tell them the actual answer instead of the smooth one. Build the evidence, slowly, that being known doesn’t have to mean being left.

Because here’s what you’re really doing with all four of these. You’re teaching your own nervous system a brand new lesson, one it never got to learn: the real me is allowed to take up space, and the people who truly love me don’t run.

Is it me, or is it us?

Now, here’s a thing that comes up constantly when women start this work, and it’s exactly why I built the tool I’m about to point you to.

You start letting the real you out, and something feels off in the relationship, and you genuinely can’t tell what it is. Is it me, finally showing up and it’s a lot to adjust to? Is it us, and we’ve built something on a performance and now the foundation’s shaky? Is it both, tangled up together? And because your default setting is “it must be me, it’s always me,” you’ll blame yourself before you’ve even looked at the situation clearly.

That’s exactly what my free quiz is for. It’s called Is It Actually Me? It’s twelve questions, it takes a few minutes, and it’s built for this exact fog. It helps you sort out what’s actually driving the stuck feeling: your wiring, your relationship, or the two of them tangled together. Because “it’s me” and “it’s us” are completely different problems with completely different solutions, and not knowing which one you’re in will keep you spinning for years.

You can take it free at JennaDalton.com/quiz. That’s JennaDalton.com/quiz.

Close

Here’s what I want you to take with you today.

You are not a fraud. You did not lie to everyone who ever loved you. You built something to stay safe, so early and so well that you didn’t even know you built it, and there is nothing shameful about that. It was the smartest thing a young, overwhelmed, misread girl could have done.

And the grief you’re feeling now, if you’re feeling it, isn’t a sign you’ve wasted your life. It’s a sign the real you is still in there, and she’s ready. Grief only shows up for the things that matter. This matters. You matter.

So this week, go find one true thing. What do you actually want for dinner? What do you actually think about that topic? What do you actually need on a Sunday? Start that small, and start that private. Then grow from there.

Thanks for hanging out with me today. Remember, you deserve to feel truly understood and deeply loved. I’ll talk to you soon.

---

Neurodivergent Love Lab is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for therapy or mental health care. If you’re in crisis, please reach out to a local crisis line or emergency service.